Paradise: An Overly Contrived Series Lacking Depth and Heart
Hulu
Paradise is a new, Hulu SciFi Drama series that explores themes of a possible life beyond apocalyptic, global events, which seemingly allows only a small minority from the United States to an underground world.
With many pertinent themes that could’ve been a great mirror for what is happening in current world affairs, the series scoffs fleshing them out for chronic cliches, generic writing and organization of the series itself, that makes dystopian commonplace, and, pushes the action to the back burner.
What is seen in the trailer is not at all what you get in the series.
Lots of questions
In the opening episodes of the show, Xavier (Sterling K. Brown) is a senior member of the “Secret Service” tasked to keep the President (James Marsden) safe. Xavier seems nothing more than a veritable robot, who is expected to take orders, no questions asked.
The series appears to take place in the United States, but we find that it is a man made version of what used to be America, with a giant lightbulb for the sun, and a computerized sky.
Above ground level is supposedly uninhabitable and the series is very vague about why at first, so we don’t have a lot of information to figure out the plot as it moves forward in shadow.
Xavier’s wife supposedly gets lost in whatever happened, so Xavier is on his own parenting their two kids, while being on call 24/7 for the President.
Xavier gets entangled in an investigation, when he finds the President dead in his room one night.
He ends up finding out that the people he depended on may not be exactly who they represent themselves to be, and his life is thrust into mystery, deceit and betrayal, up through the highest echelons.
What sounds like an intriguing story of cat and mouse woven into apocalyptic SciFi, gets muddled down into the minutia of everyday life underground. By keeping what happened above ground a secret till the very end, the desire to see the show all the way through gets harder and harder each episodes.
Throw in all of the cliches and downright silly nods to other great films, and the entire series falls flat.
IN ALL HONESTY…
Hulu
Dear Dan Fogleman, WHAT happened?
You created a gorgeous, emotionally abundant, series with all actors having chemistry, wrapped up in beautiful dialogue in This Is Us. What is this?
The filming and CGI was very well done, but with so many flaws within the construct of the series, the money spent doesn’t amount to much of anything.
Xavier is so subdued emotionally, that I barely got to see the range that I know Brown can do. Many of the supporting character actors were devoid of presence and believability as well. All of the relationships, romantic or not, are completely lacking in chemistry and emotional investment.
Perhaps the actors floundered with the absence of fleshed out characters and writing they could really sink their teeth into? I’m a fan of Sterling and Julianne Nicholson, but this was definitely beneath their abilities.
Fogleman’s ambition is there thematically but I think he may have attempted to do way too much at once, without having the urgency or know how to follow through on all of them.
Hulu
There are plenty of opportunities for the story to latch on to one of the many possible story arcs that “could’ve been”, but barely any get their due in the end. Many of them fizzle out and are never heard from again.
I think had the show started in the past, the disaster would’ve rocketed the series forward, wholly engaging the audience, and the story that follows could’ve used that as its springboard, to create a more focused, high stakes piece that definitively connected a few of the themes together.
As it is, the main plot becomes “what happened to the President'“, which negates needing them to live underground or the apocalyptic events to begin with.
Instead we see a bunch of lackluster scenes that seem to want to start totally different stories, within the overarching ones, that are disjointed, unfulfilled and disconnected.
After such events, any commonplace occurrence not connected to it, trying to be like what life used to be before it, is rendered dull and moot.
Why would the people that survived such devastating consequences, caused at least partially by human greed and ignorance, want to have the governments/systems run just like they used to?
They somehow have agreed with the continuance of the boring, white guy, and an alcoholic “President”, in a cookie cutter “American country'“ that no longer exists.
No one really likes him to begin with, but somehow we’re supposed to be invested in his death, and, the same real life scenario of toxic wealthy elites holding all of the power?
That story wrap up also was unfulfilling and predictable.
The sheer amount of cliches used throughout is astounding. Some 85% of this series, characters are either at the bar “coping” with what is going on, or just drinking at home.
I feel like if these people could make it through apocalyptic events, they could easily cope with all of the other story’s events that pale in comparison.
One major cliche uses a character who “knows stuff” about what’s happened to the President. They tell Xavier one night, that they have to talk to him about it over a casual instance.
For some unknown reason, nothing plausible, they can’t tell him at the moment, when they had time, and, because of that, guess what happens to them next.
Hulu
There were also multiple times that the main villain could’ve been easily killed throughout the show, given the amount of characters who are ex military/mercenaries. Even when said villain threatens someone’s life, in a one on one scenario, with no one else around, the threatened person just decides to leave.
Further in, something gets “written” on the sky, in an act of rebellion. When no one higher up can remove it for some reason, they want to reboot it. One of the characters, using an awful Disney ride metaphor, warns them that it could cause all kinds of “havoc” from the people because they would “remember” where they were.
From what I could tell, they hadn’t been there for long anyway, and, having lived through what they did, OF COURSE they would know where they are and why the sky might shut off. It’s a computer and they are already practiced in sky and sun shutdowns!
After all of this, they force in some quotes from Die Hard, in such cringe inducing ways, that the series, not the apocalyptic events, is the true disaster. All that is left to say or think is WHY ?
Why was this important to make? What were the story creators going for? What themes did they want to follow? Why was much of the script just filler for the main action pieces, which had no real urgency to begin with? Why did they make something akin to the old 1980’s, night time soaps?
The world may never know.
Now, since Disney readily and willingly shut down their DEI programs, bowing to fascism and bigotry, why would any artist or general laborer want to work for them or their businesses again?